General Order 1: no interference with a people who haven’t reached warp, not even to let them know you exist. A board of inquiry gives you a case where it and the right thing pull apart. Give your orders, and the board grades your compassion, restraint, judgment and candour, and tells you what a captain on screen did. Nobody earns all four.
Board of inquiry · Finding
What happened
On screen
Also at the Academy: the Kobayashi Maru, the no-win test, and the Bridge Officer’s Test on its briefing.
General Order 1, the Prime Directive, is Starfleet’s from the first series on. The case, its world and its people are this game’s; the account of “Pen Pals” is from Wikipedia’s article on the episode. The grades are the board’s opinion, not a rule: another board might weigh them differently.